During his 50-year career, Neil Diamond dominated the music charts, sold 120 million albums, and created classics like “Sweet Caroline” that now, a new generation has embraced as an anthem of joy and love — it’s so good, so good.
Millions of fans worldwide knew all about the fabled singer/songwriter on stage, but very few, even Diamond himself, knew the inner workings of the man. That becomes obvious in The Neil Diamond Musical — A Beautiful Noise, which opened Tuesday night at Altria Theater and plays through Sunday.
A mashup between a biographical drama and jukebox musical, A Beautiful Noise opens with a more senior Diamond, played by Robert Westenberg (who I had the pleasure of interviewing last week), sitting across from a therapist. He lets it be known that he wouldn’t be there if it wasn’t for his wife, Katie, who strongly encouraged him to go.
At first, he is hesitant about opening up for fear of what he might uncover, but when the therapist brings out a large book filled with the lyrics from all of his songs and begins to read them as she flips through the pages, the journey through Diamond’s feelings and songbook begins.
Memories Come Alive on Stage
Neil “Now” watches as Neil Diamond “Then” moves from an unknown to a star with accomplishments that made him, as he says, bigger than Elvis.
As each song unfolds, we learn more about Diamond’s life behind the glitzy outfits and persona on stage. And those discoveries don’t always put Diamond in the best light. Kudos to the real Neil Diamond, who collaborated with the show creators, for putting his life out there for all to see. That takes bravery.
What I saw at Altria Theater had the glitz, the sequins, the music, and heart. The entire cast showed talent and stamina, which is required for the energetic show that moves like a graceful-but-purposeful cheetah across time. Scenes change right before your eyes, even though you are often oblivious to the change.
The singers and dancers that make up “the beautiful noise” — think the noise that reverberates through Diamond’s mind — are consistently on stage moving the action. Their combined talent helps create a dynamic that is necessary for the show, as does the show’s scenic and lighting design.
Exceptional Performances
There were many actors that stood out, including Kate Mulligan who plays the spirited Ellie Greenwich, the music producer who discovers Neil Diamond; Hannah Jewel Kohn who plays Marcia Murphey, Diamond’s second wife; Lisa Reneé Pitts, who plays the therapist, and a special shout out to Spencer Donovan Jones for his “Shilo” solo.
The show wouldn’t be what it is without the extreme talent of Nick Fradiani, who plays Neil “Then”, and Robert Westenberg who plays Neil “Now”. Fradiani, the 2015 winner of American Idol, embodies the persona of Diamond in his younger years. His voice is magnificent and so reminiscent of Diamond’s distinctive vocals. But, mind you, neither he nor Westenberg, who also has a beautiful voice, are mimicking Diamond — they are interpreting the legendary singer. There is a huge difference.
Both actors, who by the way resemble each other in stature and frame — you nailed it casting! — lead you on a journey that is both invigorating and lonely, a path of discovery that is authentic, believable and raw.
Their stunning duo of Diamond’s song “I Am … I Said” pulls at the heartstrings when the two come together and face each other as Diamond finally discovers who he really is.
“Working with Bob has been so enjoyable, but also a great learning experience for me,” says Nick. “I am relatively new to musical theater, so his advice and encouragement on the work I’m doing has been truly incredible. He’s a force out there, and we’ve really worked to put out the best possible show together.”
A Beautiful Noise will give you a new appreciation for Neil Diamond and his music. Whether you are a lifelong fan or you’re new to his music, this is a show you don’t want to miss.
Postscript: The opening night show had a little added excitement at the end, thanks to local CBS 6 personalities Mike Stone and Greg McQuade, who were invited onstage to join the cast in leading an audience singalong of “Sweet Caroline.” Greg — great job, great stage presence. Mike — perhaps you should stick to your day job, predicting the weather. Just kidding!
The Neil Diamond Musical — A Beautiful Noise is on stage at Altria Theater through Sunday, April 20. Discounted tickets through RFM are available here.
